The State of Pizza in the Pizza State

Pizza in New York is a lot like certain calculus problems (or that one scene in “Mean Girls”): The limit does not exist. We will never reach peak pizza, barring some pizza-related disaster. Which brings us to this year’s State of Pizza, my second annual update on the latest pizza goings-on across this big, beautiful, pepperoni-peppered city.

The Chrissy’s Pizza operation is a small one, operated out of the old Superiority Burger space by Christopher Hansell, right, Chelsea O’Connor and Christopher Fratesi.Credit…Maansi Srivastava/The New York Times

A New New York Slice

Last year around this time, I was singing the praises of the clam pizza from Andrew Bellucci’s Pizzeria in Astoria, Queens. So, I was heartbroken to learn of the sudden death of Mr. Bellucci, the restaurant’s co-owner, in May. He had a complicated past, but one thing was never in doubt: He knew how to make pizza, and he knew how to make it exceptionally well.

He was also generous with that knowledge, and showed the ropes to Chris Hansell, the pizzaiolo behind Chrissy’s Pizza. If you haven’t heard of Chrissy’s, prepare to hear about it nonstop once it opens to the public (hopefully) in late August. It started as a passion project in Mr. Hansell’s apartment in Bushwick, Brooklyn, and through word of mouth — and a co-sign from the rapper Action Bronson — it’s become New York City’s hardest-to-get pie.

That’s not on purpose, by the way: The three-person operation is now based in the shoebox-size space in the East Village that Superiority Burger used to occupy and can produce only about 60 pies a day. I tried one of Chrissy’s “test” pies just before pickup last week — the shop is currently in “beta” and fulfilling long-sold-out preorders. I think I blacked out. This is the pie for anyone who loves an extra crispy, well-done crust, the kind that was perfected in neighborhood pizza parlors, many of which Mr. Hansell frequented with his father, whose picture sits in two places in the restaurant. The tomato sauce is made fresh, never sitting in a fridge for hours on end, with just a smattering of cheese. You won’t get those legendary Ninja Turtle cheese pulls, but the pizza won’t last long enough for you to care.

The cracker-thin red pie from Lala’s Brooklyn Apizza in East Williamsburg.Credit…Rachel Vanni

And a New New Haven Slice

If Chrissy’s is repping the New York pie, then Lala’sin East Williamsburg, Brooklyn, is the Connecticut delegate. This city isn’t exactly head over heels for rival pizza styles, so it’s particularly brave of Grimm Artisanal Ales to give over its entire rooftop to apizza (the New Haven term for its local style). I’ve been a fan of Grimm for a long time — it was going hard on light-bodied sours during the New England I.P.A. arms race — and the lovely little restaurant its owners have put together is perfect for a group hang or a first date. Go for the tomato pie, a cracker-thin pizza with shaved garlic, or the cozy pie with chunks of potato. And if beer isn’t quite your thing, don’t fret: Grimm now makes and serves its own wine.

You want New York pizza? All right, it’s finally time for me to shout from the rooftops that one of the best and most underrated grandma pies in this city comes from Rocco Pizza, which advertises itself as “the last Italian family-owned pizza joint in Bed-Stuy, Brooklyn.” For years now, I’ve been inviting friends over for drinks and Rocco, and there’s no greater pleasure than watching the surprise on their faces at just how good the crisp, buttery crust and cheesy interior are. I’ve held my silence long enough!

Slices like the Hotboi (pictured above) and whole pies are available at the new, larger location of Scarr’s Pizza.Credit…Karsten Moran for The New York Times

A Lightning Round of Impressive Pies and Super Slices

Scarr’s Pizza moved to a new, larger location across the street on the Lower East Side, and it’s serving slices until 11 p.m. or midnight. The new spot to be seen eating pizza with a Lambrusco spritz in hand is Manero’s of Mulberry. The most inventive pizza in the city isn’t being made in shops, it’s being baked in portable ovens by nomads like Happy Bull Pizza, Traze and Wizard Hat Pizza. Have you been craving bulgolgi or kimchi on your pie? Try Appas Pizza in the East Village, or the new Bushwick location of Nowon. The chef Wylie Dufresne got into the pizza game with Stretch Pizza, but it’s his appetizers that really shine, according to Pete Wells. If you’re deadly serious about natural wine and margherita pizza, Decades Pizza in Ridgewood, Queens, is the answer. And as the food writer Mahira Rivers reminded us a few months ago on Eater, take good care of your pizza elders. They won’t be around forever.

In Other News …

  • There’s no restaurant review this week, which means you can catch up on Pete Wells’s most recent reviews of the Peruvian restaurant Artesano, Potluck Club in Chinatown and Mischa, home of the $29 hot dog.

  • Openings: Spain and Japan meet at the Bazaar by José Andrés at the Ritz-Carlton in NoMad; starting Wednesday, L’abeille à côté will serve French-Japanese in a more casual setting right next to the Michelin-starred L’abeille; and Gulaabo, a new destination for Punjabi cuisine, is now open on West 47th Street.

  • Record heat has made cooking at certain kinds of restaurants more difficult, forcing owners to purchase new equipment or change their hours of operation, Christina Morales reports.

  • How has the cooking video evolved? Priya Krishna and Umi Syam put together a visual deep dive into the history of the medium going back to the days of Joyce Chen and James Beard and landing on the distinct styles that have been created on Tiktok.

  • After a recent crackdown, food vendors at Corona Plaza in Queens and their supporters are looking for a fast track that will allow them to sell their goods legally, Stefanos Chen and Raúl Vilchis report.

  • Robert Simonson traveled to Binghamton, N.Y., to report on the Spiedie Fest and Balloon Rally Expo, a celebration of the regional sandwich made with grilled, marinated meat.

Email us at [email protected]. Newsletters will be archived here. Follow NYT Food on TikTok and NYT Cooking on Instagram, Facebook, YouTube and Pinterest.

Back to top button